Enjoyed: Sunday, June 27 , 2021
Listed on the menu: No, but this was a restaurant inside a casino, for heaven’s sake, and the bar looked to be very well-stocked. And yes, an Old Fashioned could be made! Shortly after my first sip, I asked our waitperson about the ingredients. She sent the bartender our way, and he happily explained his version of the cocktail to us.
Ingredients: Yellowstone Select Kentucky Straight Bourbon, caramel simple syrup made with a Four Roses Bourbon reduction, bitters, large ice cube, orange slice, maraschino cherry.
The occasion: This evening was our second in Deadwood, and the end of our sixth day of vacation. In the morning, we drove to Wyoming to see Devil’s Tower National Monument. (Yes, so worth the trip!) After a hike around the base of the tower, we drove home via Sundance (yes, and posed for photos with a statue of the Sundance Kid) and then down the Spearfish Canyon Byway. (Wow, this part of the world is so beautiful!) We are not gamblers, so the casinos did not entice us, but the restaurant’s high ratings did. We opted for the $42 per person all-you-can-eat tasting menu. The restaurant was only half-full this evening, so the chef actually came to our table several times to ask which “petite” dishes we enjoyed most–and he suggested a few of his favorites. By the end of our long meal, we had sampled blue-cheese wedge salad, Caesar salad, sashimi, grilled shrimp cocktail (Husband’s favorite), bison filet with hearts of palm, filet mignon with cherries (my favorite), asparagus, twice-baked potato, salmon, scallops, cheesecake, and chocolate-coconut gelato. Best meal of our entire trip!
My rating: ***** of 5. The bartender was proud of his work–all our drinks this evening were delicious. The Old Fashioned was as carefully thought out as all the food on the menu. The rich caramel flavors– from both bourbons he used– coated my mouth in a most pleasant way.
Final thoughts: We spent more money tonight on alcohol than on food. (Oh, boy!) And then the restaurant offered us $20 of free play at the slot machines. (We didn’t win anything.) We asked the chef how he kept his prices so low, and he chuckled and told us that the casino was heavily subsidizing his costs. So, we would like to thank all the Tin Lizzie patrons for helping us to have an incredible experience.