
Enjoyed: Friday, April 5, 2024
Listed on the menu: Yes, as “1881 Old Fashion” (sic).
Ingredients: Four Roses Bourbon, Aromatic Bitters, House-Made Porter Syrup, with an orange peel and a maraschino cherry.
The occasion: When I learned that my son and his fiancée were traveling to my sister-in-law’s home for the solar eclipse, I promptly decided that we needed to join in the fun. Happily, my sister-in-law and her husband were sweet enough to accommodate all of us, so I started planning our trip to Indianapolis, which was in the path of totality. How fortunate for us all! I wanted to break up the nine-plus hour drive with an overnight stop along the way, and perhaps a bit of sightseeing. Chillicothe, Ohio, seemed like a perfect location, since we wanted to see the Leo Petroglyphs and to tour the Westcott House (designed by Frank Lloyd Wright) in Springfield, Ohio. Chillicothe’s charming historic district had several interesting options for supper and a drink.
My rating: **** out of 5. I picked this restaurant since it advertised thirty beers on draft. I was not surprised, therefore, that this cocktail used beer in its signature house-made simple syrup. The deep porter flavor plus the always-lovely Four Roses bourbon made the drink taste rich and almost creamy. I would have awarded an extra star, however, if the bartender had rubbed the orange peel around the rim and if the cherry had not been a maraschino.
Final thoughts: We really do need to visit more small Midwestern cities. Downtown Chillicothe, for example, contains lovely architecture and fun places to eat and drink at very reasonable prices. (Full disclosure: our first stop of the evening was a bar called “Steiner’s Speakeasy” and I paved the way for this Old Fashioned with an award-winning margarita made with Mexican-street-corn-flavored simple syrup. So good. Seems like Chillicothe’s bartenders are creative with simple syrup!) Oh, and the total eclipse of the sun? We had clear skies and a clear view. Worth the trip for this once-in-a-lifetime, breathtaking event.








